Best Putters for High Handicappers: 5 Top Choices

If you are a high handicapper, you’ll know all about how selecting the right clubs can make a huge difference to your game. In particular, putters are one of the most important types of golfing equipment to get right, as putting can all too often make or break a round of golf. 

If you’re looking to swap out your putters for new, we’re here to help. In this article, we’re going to be taking you through the best putters for high handicappers available to buy right now, as well as some pointers on what to look for when selecting the right putter. Ready? Just keep reading. 

Are you in a hurry? Check out our top pick:

The Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter takes first place. Besides its affordable price point, this PGX Putter is a bestseller for its ability to offer the user total precision thanks to its white finish which stands out at address position.

It’s a favorite in the golfing community for its ability to encourage the player to maintain focus on the alignment lines, which delivers more consistent putter shots. 

OUR TOP PICK

Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter

EDITORS CHOICE

New SeeMore FGP Mallet Black Putter

BEST VALUE

GoSports The Classic Golf Putter

OUR TOP PICK

Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter

The cost of equipment, especially in golf, can add up quickly. If you’re on the search for a high-quality putter that isn’t going to break the bank, then the Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter is a worthy option to consider. 

Where do we begin? From affordability to quality, the PGX Putter is a favorite for a reason. Though it might not be as durable as some other putters on the market, this budget putter has plenty to offer and is a great choice for the mid to high handicapper.

For starters, the Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX Putter has a white finish which gives great contrast. This helps with alignment and leads to greater accuracy and precision. 

This is because the bright white color of this putter contrasts with the green of the grass, which increases focus and makes the alignment lines easier to use.

Not only that, but this mallet-style putter has been built with an additional weight of 40g on top of the standard weight of 380g. This additional weight allows for a good weight balance that will help with control and target precision.

In particular, this PGX Putter plays particularly well across ‘faster’ greens, which are being seen more commonly on most golf courses, so it’s a great putter to have in your golf bag.

Plus, Pinemeadow has specifically created this style and design to be a lot easier for high handicappers to use.

Thanks to the comfort and ease of use, you’ll be able to enjoy great consistency and accuracy with the addition of this putter to your collection. 

Pros

• Suitable for mid to high handicappers
• Affordable
• Great weight balance

Cons

• Some users find that the white can begin to chip over time

EDITORS CHOICE

New SeeMore FGP Mallet Black Putter

Our runner up is the New SeeMore FGP Mallet Black Putter, and it’s all thanks to its fantastic dot alignment system designed to help high-handicappers achieve overall consistency.

SeeMore is a company loved by many pro golfers for its brilliant alignment system, known as RifleScope Technology, which is a simple yet effective way to get the putter face pointed in the right direction, which is highly suited to a high handicappers game. 

The bottom of the putter shaft has been painted black. Across the top of the putter, you’ll find a large red dot in between two white lines. When in play, after you have placed this putter behind the ball, the black part of the shaft will conceal the red dot, and the two white lines will serve as alignment aids. 

In addition, the putter is face balanced, which means that it’s been strategically balanced to optimize itself to the angle you putt, and then naturally return itself to square at impact. This will allow for less manipulation during the stroke in order to keep the putter face on the right target. 

Plus, It’s cast 303 stainless steel face features a black powder coat finish that will eliminate glare, so you can use it in the sun without any issues. Paired with the high MOI of the putter, this FGP mallet putter will help you to make more accurate putt shots. 

Pros

• The white lines across the black putter face make for excellent visuals
• Patented Riflescope Technology encourages better consistency and target accuracy
• Solid feel to encourage confidence at address

Cons

• Some players might not like the chunky feel

BEST VALUE

GoSports The Classic Golf Putter

High-handicappers often benefit from clubs that are a little lighter in order to make swinging easier, and the GoSports The Classic Golf Putter caters to this issue. 

Featuring a classic design, this stylish putter features a synthetic material with a cast iron exterior. It has been designed in the USA and has been made with a focus on durability, and GoSports boast that this putter will consistently provide putter rolls, time and time again. 

Ideal for most adults, this Classic Golf Putter is a traditional 35 inches long and has been designed to help high-handicappers master their short games skills. It can even be used by both male and women golfers. 

Besides improving accuracy, this putter can even be used by both left or right high-handicappers, which is particularly impressive given its price point. It features an ambidextrous rubberized grip that will provide great comfort and stability.

Pros

• Classic design
• Can be used by both right or left-handed putters
• Affordable

Cons

• Some state that this putter is only ideal for practice games

RUNNER UP

Callaway Golf Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter

Are you a high-handicapper that wants to improve your overall performance? If so, the Callaway Golf Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter might be the putter that your collection is missing. 

Boasting a re-engineered Callaway patented White hot insert, the Golf Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter is able to not only promote your overall performance and accuracy, but it also provides an excellent feel while standing at address.

Suited to a high-handicapper, Callaway has increased the forgiveness of this putter by strategically placing the weight into the heel/toe of the putter’s face. By placing the weight here, Callaway has ensured that this putter offers more responsiveness on strikes taken across the face.

In addition to the heel/toe weight, the laser milling insert cutting process during the manufacturing process helps to create tighter tolerances, which helps to achieve more consistent performance. 

Plus, even though it doesn’t have a color that will look striking against the green grass, it does have vibrant white alignment aids against its black color design. This will help to promote better accuracy and increased stroke consistency. 

Pros

• Made of steel to increase durability
• Vibrant white alignment aids to increase accuracy and consistency
• Ideal for high-handicappers, the heel/toe placement helps to increase overall forgiveness

Cons

• The black color does not stand out against the grass

Best Putters for High Handicappers Buying Guide

Before you go ahead and make a purchase, check out our helpful guide below which will help you decide which putter is right for you:

Appearance

Usually, the appearance of any type of golfing equipment isn’t usually a top priority. However, when it comes to selecting a putter, the appearance (or looks) is very important to consider.

In fact, it’s a surefire way of figuring out how effective the putter is going to be! Oftentimes, a putter will feature numerous different alignment aids such as dots, lines or aids.

Depending on your personal preference, you might like a putter that has minimal alignment aids, or perhaps you’d prefer long lines or other types of vibrant alignment visuals. 

The easiest way for you to decide is by going off of first looks. As soon as you hold the putter in your hand, stand at address and get a feel for how it looks when you stand behind it. 

Rolling Ability

Another important feature to consider when selecting a high-handicapper friendly putter is whether or not the putter is going to be able to get the ball rolling quickly.

This might seem obvious, but we think you’d be surprised at the number of putters that cause the ball to ‘hop’ or veer off track before actually beginning to roll properly.

If a putter causes the ball to do this, it can cause the ball to fall short of the hole, or roll-off track completely.

Therefore, as the goal is to make sure that the ball is rolling as smoothly as possible, make sure that the putter you select has been designed to counteract the ball getting knocked offline. 

Forgiveness

In theory, it should be pretty easy to achieve consistent putting strokes, especially as the putter is often close to the hole.

However, it’s a lot more complicated than that. Even the smoothest, most-advanced putters can produce mis-hits!

When you’re picking a putter, make sure to keep an eye out for putters that will be able to produce playable results, no matter where it is on the face that the putt has been struck from the ball.

More: Can you change golf balls when putting?

Feel

It’s difficult to pinpoint ‘feel’ and how it can impact your game because the overall feel of a putter is going to be different for everyone.

However, when selecting your putter, you’ll want to choose one that is going to make you feel confident at address. It should feel good in your hands and you should feel comfortable using it.

Another overlooked aspect of ‘feel’ is the sound! Most putters create that satisfying ‘click’ upon impact, while others make an offputting (pardon the pun) sound that could push you out of focus and lead you to mis-hit. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Which type of putter should I use, blade or mallet?

The two types of putter styles that you’ll be able to choose from are what is known as a mallet and a blade. Blade putters are often characterized by small, narrow heads and feature very minimal alignment aids.

For this reason, blade putters are believed to be best suited to players that are able to consistently hit the middle of the putter in the center of the face.  

On the other hand, mallet putters feature much larger heads and usually feature much larger sweet spots. As mallet putters have a much higher MOI, they are generally considered to be most suited to players that have a high handicap or players with straight back straight strokes. 

As a high-handicapper, should I use an offset putter?

Not necessarily. An offset putter is a type of putter that features a hosel that is strategically placed back from where the putter shaft connects to it.

If it doesn’t feature a hosel that has been positioned towards the back, it will feature a shaft that is bent so that the putter head is able to sit directly behind the grip of the shaft.

Most straight-shaft putters (which are the standard shaft design for putters) cater to those with a high-handicap, however, if you do feel like you might need to use an offset putter, the easiest way to decide is by analyzing your eye dominance. 

If you have a lead eye that is dominant, then you should go for a straight-shafted putter. However, if your trailing eye is dominant, then you should consider using a half or full offset putter.

Although, this isn’t an exact science. If you’re ever unsure, why not visit your local golfing store and try a few different putter offsets? It could make all the difference to your putting accuracy.