The Ultimate Guide to the 8 Best Mallet Putters

Your subpar putter may be the one thing holding you back from getting the best game. Mallet putters are a fantastic addition to your bag if you want better stability and precision.

Read our guide to find the best mallet putter for you!

8 Best Mallet Putters

Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter: Best Overall Pick


Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter

Key Specs

  • Putter length: 33, 34, or 35 inches (customizable)
  • Flex: Regular
  • Material: Alloy steel and graphite
  • Loft:3 degrees

For those looking for the ultimate best putter, this is it. Odyssey made their Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter for serious golfers and pros.

Odyssey has let the charge when it comes to game-changing putters, which is why they have produced some of the best mallet putter models available on the market.

THIS particular putter is the best of the best.

Their stroke lab putters are unique because they use their lab shaft technology. Odyssey has developed the perfect golf shaft to complement its fantastic putter heads.

What’s the Result?

You get a shaft that’s made from a combination of steel and graphite, which gives you the stiffness your steel offers while also reducing a tremendous amount of weight.

In turn, this has allowed the weight to be redistributed elsewhere in the golf club.

This weight distribution resulted in:

  • More forgiveness
  • Better speed control
  • More responsive feel

Moreover, this mallet putter was designed to suit all players of any handicap level, which means ANYONE will benefit from its design.

Plus, it offers incredible stability and increased forgiveness because the multi-material construction balances the weight and makes it HARDER TO MISS your shots.

Let’s Not Discount Its Looks

This is one sexy, sleek black putter that also has easily visible alignment lines, so it looks good and plays well. Its distinct alignment line across the top will help you sink all those shots.

We also love the soft feel Micro Hinge Star inserts that will give you a fantastic sound upon impact and a slightly firmer feel than their other insert models.

For an even better feel, you can choose between either an oversized or standard grip.

Pros

  • Sightlines easy to see
  • High-performance face insert
  • Forging on off-center hits
  • Fantastic stability
  • Increased forgiveness
  • Customizable length

Cons

  • Expensive

TaylorMade Golf Spider X Putter: Best Value Pick

TaylorMade Golf Spider X Putter, Copper/White, #3 Hosel

Key Specs

  • Putter shaft length:34 inches
  • Flex: Stiff
  • Material: Alloy steel
  • Loft: 3 degrees

This TaylorMade mallet putter can easily outperform any putter out there.

While it may cost a lot more than the average putter, the Spider X still offers a lot of fantastic features if you’re looking for a professional putter.

TaylorMade is well-known for its golf clubs, and it also deserves its excellent reputation as a putter brand. The Spider X is their latest model that features the best they have to offer.

You can expect to get top-notch stability and alignment for straighter putts and fantastic distance control.

Why Can You Achieve These?

The True Path Alignment System seeks to help golfers of all skill levels and handicaps get online and stay on track.

They’ve aimed to create a new putter that will help you get better visualization so you can sink all your putts. The head was also redesigned to be 30% heavier to minimize any twisting upon impact.

This will give you the consistency you need to get a good hit again and again.

It also uses a 320-gram frame and perimeter weighting. If that’s not enough, you also get adjustable weights!

You can choose between using their 2g, 6g, and 12g weights that easily fit into the built-in weight ports.

What Does This Mean?

Well, it’s a breeze to get the exact feel and balance point you want according to your playing style and preferences.

Remember that when it comes to putting, even the smallest adjustments can make or break your performance. This brand new putter will help you get closer to that!

Pros

  • Interchangeable weights for toe hang
  • Amazing feel
  • Heavier club head for stability
  • Perimeter weighting
  • Multiple colors and styles
  • Double-bend shaft

Cons

  • Expensive

Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX: Best Budget Pick

Pinemeadow Golf Men's PGX Putter

Key Specs

  • Size:34 inches
  • Flex: not specified
  • Material: Aluminum
  • Loft:3 degrees

Putters range from hundreds of dollars to less than fifty. But despite its reasonable price tag at about 1/10 of the top-of-the-line models, you’ll still get a decent mallet putter.

For its price, this is an incredible bargain. You’ll love this putter as long as you manage your expectations.

DON’T expect a high-performance putter like the top models on this list, but it’s certainly more than enough for the price if you don’t have the money to spend or are just beginning your golf journey.

We love its white finish because it makes it easy to align your shots. It gives you a GREAT contrast from the green of the grass.

Plus, there are also black lines on top to further help you straighten out your putts.

They also incorporated tour weighting here, so if you play on faster greens, you’ll have no problem getting the ball rolling at the speed you want.

This is also a fantastic option if you’re thinking of transitioning to mallet putters but want to feel it out before you take the plunge.

What Are the Downsides?

We must warn you that the paint tends to start chipping if you don’t take care of the putter head enough.

Also, note that we do not recommend this for low handicap players.

Pros

  • White finish for straightforward alignment line
  • Comes with headcover
  • Unbeatable price
  • With toe hang

Cons

  • Paint can chip if not maintained
  • Not for low handicap golfers

Cleveland Golf Frontline Cero Putter

Cleveland Golf Frontline Cero Putter

Key Specs

  • Size: 33, 34, or 35 inches
  • Flex: Regular
  • Material: Steel
  • Loft: 3 degrees

This medium-priced putter is a new release from Cleveland that has proven to be a welcome addition to the market for players with a high handicap or serious beginners.

Its unique design will give you increased stability and better consistency, along with high forgiveness to better sink your shots.

While this may not look like traditional putter heads, it’s all about the performance. And on THAT, Cleveland delivers.

You’ll be getting a mallet putter that’s unmatched in its stability and ability to produce accurate putts.

How so? It contains a tungsten forward weighting system and a center of gravity that was positioned closer to the face of the putter head.

What Else Does It Offer?

Cleveland also placed a speed-optimized face on the putter head to help regulate your ball speed. While this means that you won’t get the fastest balls here, there’s a good reason for this choice.

You see, since it was developed for beginners, it aims to help you improve your base skills as much as possible.

The speed-optimized face will help you develop a more consistent stroke so that you can play well regardless of what you’re holding.

They aimed to do one thing well: CONSISTENCY. And in both its results and performance, you can certainly see your speed and distance control improve with this mallet putter.

Pros

  • Great aiming technology
  • Extremely stable
  • High handicapper benefit from better consistency
  • Adjustable for toe hang

Cons

  • Not the cheapest option
  • Not for those looking for 1 sold line

Odyssey Red O-Works

Callaway Golf Steel 7 Ss Pistol 33' Length Odyssey O Works 17 7 Red Putter, Right Hand

Key Specs

  • Size: 33 inches
  • Flex: Regular
  • Material: Steel
  • Loft: not specified

This is an example of an oldie but goodie. While it may not feature the most updated technologies, the Odyssey Red O-Works is still one of the most face-balanced putters available out there.

The Odyssey Red Series still produced some of the best mallet putters out there because it comes in various tour-proven head shapes.

This means that pros have tried them out and seen the results for themselves, so it’s excellent for all kinds of golfers.

Using a combination of red and distinct white lines on the top of the club, you can easily visualize your shots and get the perfect alignment.

The Micro Hinge Face also helps create a solid forward role that will travel along your intended alignment line.

Because this is a High MOI putter with a midsize grip, the Red O-Works is perfect for mid handicappers who need to use less of their hands and more of their shoulders in their putting stroke.

Pros

  • High MOI putter
  • Micro Hinge face putter shape
  • Red and Whiteface for contrast

Cons

  • Pricey
  • Not updated technology
  • No shaft advancements

Wilson Staff Harmonized Putter

WILSON Staff Harmonized Putter - Men's

Key Specs

  • Size: 35 inches
  • Flex: not specified
  • Material: Steel
  • Loft: 1 degree

If you’re a beginner or high-handicapper looking for an entry-level putter, this is one of the best mallet putters you can get.

The vertical seam grip will give you a better feel and more responsiveness so you can adjust your shots and know when you’ve hit the sweet spot.

At the same time, it also helps you get improved tension throughout your stroke.

This is one of the best mallet putters out there because of the flared rear of the sole, which creates a more balanced head with even weighting for more consistent and dependable shots.

It comes with a polymer injected insert to give you a soft feel. However, some have noticed that you may register differing speeds and distances because of this insert.

Despite that, we still consider this one of the best mallet putters you can get for a consistent roll.

For its price, you get fantastic features for better stability and consistency to help improve your game.

Pros

  • Face insert for soft feel
  • Offset hosel helps with alignment
  • Better balance and stability

Cons

  • Issues with the insert

Cleveland Huntington Beach #11 SOFT Putter

Cleveland Golf 2019 Huntington Beach SOFT Putter #11

Key Specs

  • Size: 33 inches
  • Flex: Uniflex
  • Material: alloy steel
  • Loft: 3 degrees

For the best mallet putter with a milled face, you can’t go wrong with the Cleveland Huntington #11 soft putter.

Its speed-optimized milled face design will help grip the ball upon impact and reduce mishits so you can get your ball moving as quickly as possible.

The stainless steel shaft also gives you a strong grip, durable shaft, and premium feel. The diamond CNC milling pattern features deep grooves for a soft feel and a true roll that starts on the line.

We also love the optimized CG location, which accounts for their strategic weight redistribution.

The result is a solid mallet putter that gives you fantastic responsiveness and stability for straighter putts.

Pros

  • Distinct alignment lines
  • Milled face
  • Well-balanced

Cons

  • Small club head

Evnroll ER10 Outback Mallet Putter

Evnroll ER10 Outback Mallet Putter RH Mallet 35 Pistol Black

Key Specs

  • Size: 35 inches
  • Flex: not specified
  • Material: Steel
  • Loft: 2 degrees

If you’re looking for the best mallet putter for the highest forgiveness, this is it. Evnroll [R]is famous for making the best mallet putters on the market, and for good reason.

Okay, so this may cost, well, a lot. BUT bear with us here.

The ER1o Outback is one of the most forgiving putters ever made.

It uses their patented face-milled Evnroll grooves and visual alignment dots to give you a BETTER chance of hitting the ball as close to the hole as possible.

This means you get more accurate putts from heel and toe strikes.

It also features deep perimeter weighting to help you control your ball speeds and avoid mishits for better lag putting at ANY handicap and skill level.

This makes it perfect for players who prioritize functionality and want the utmost best for improving their putts.

Pros

  • Unbeatable forgiveness
  • Fantastic alignment
  • Stable and consistent

Cons

  • Expensive

What Is a Putter?

Arguably the most important item in your golf bag, you wouldn’t want to go wrong with your choice of mallet putter.

But what IS a mallet putter? What are its uses?

If you don’t already know, there are 3 main types of clubs that every golfer needs to have:

  • Driver
  • Irons
  • Putter

A putter has 2 kinds: a blade and a mallet.

Putters are used to making relatively short and low-speed strokes with your clubs to get your ball moving somewhere close.

Typically, you’ll be reaching for one of these once your golf ball has reached the green when you need to get it into the hole.

As we’ve mentioned, there are 2 kinds of putters. Both of them have pros and cons that emanate from their design. Let’s go through them, shall we?

Blade Putter vs. Mallet Putter 101

There’s an endless debate among golfers about which one’s the best putter. Even pros are split on this topic, with blade putters just edging out the competition by a hair.

Ultimately, the choice will rest on a lot of individualized factors that depend on many things. But first, let’s go through what their differences are.

Blade Putter

A blade putter uses the traditional club head shape, making this part a favorite among golf ‘purists.’ Blade putters have a sweet spot closer toward the heel.

This sweet spot position is because they’re heavily toe-weighted, with the shaft connecting to the club head of the blade at the heel or sometimes even the center of the blade.

This weighting and sweet spot mean that the design of blade putters will usually suit players who have more of an arc in their putting stroke.

Mallet Putter

Today, the more modern mallet putter is a flat stick with a larger head than you’d see on a blade putter. The heads come in various shapes and sizes.

Because of this increase in size, most weight is typically distributed AWAY from the club face. This helps players find more stability and balance in their stroke.

Typically, mallet-style putters are also referred to as “game improvement putters.”

This refers to its larger sweet spot, which will help golfers, especially beginners, who struggle with striking the ball directly in the center of the face.

Moreover, the added weight in the head will help keep the putter from twisting during the stroke.

This can also benefit golfers who have difficulty hitting putts hard enough due to the mallet’s heavier weight, which gives golfers that extra boost.

Moreover, mallet putters also help you align your shots because their design offers more prominent features than a blade putter.

For example, you may notice that a mallet putter features longer or added lines.

So What’s the Difference?

It’s easily visible when you look at these 2 putters side-by-side. A mallet uses a MUCH BIGGER clubhead that extends outwards, much further than you’d see in a traditional blade putter.

Mallets also have noticeably longer alignment lines than blade putters. Plus, they are usually more forgiving.

Traditional golfers would tell you those blade putters are for lower handicap players, and mallet putters are for beginners. But this isn’t necessarily true anymore.

Manufacturers have improved the technology used in mallet putters. Today, its club face is just as responsive and stable as a blade.

The choice of the right putter for your game will depend on your preference and playing style. Basically, the technology or feature differences between mallets and blades won’t matter that much.

A person who swings the club straight back and through may prefer mallet putters more, while someone with more of an arc to their stroke may benefit more from blade putters.

But don’t worry if you feel torn now. We’ll go into more detail about what you should consider when choosing between these 2 below.

Blade Putter vs. Mallet Putter: Which One’s Right for You?

This choice usually comes down to 2 things: feel and stroke. And just like any other club in your golf bag, don’t forget to try fitting and testing.

Different Strokes for Different Folks

Your stroke [R] is unique, just like all the pros out there. This will determine the right style of putter for you because one may help you perform better on the greens than others.

There are two prominent strokes you’ll typically see on the course. Figuring out the category you fall into will greatly help you identify the best type of putter for you.

Try it out now and pay attention to the details we’ll mention below.

Square-to-Square Stroke

A square-to-square stroke or a straight stroke is when the putter face lines up squarely with your target, with the stroke going straight back and through.

If you use a natural square-to-square stroke, you’re likely more suited to a mallet putter.

This is because a mallet putter has a MORE balanced face, with the center of gravity positioned toward the back of the club.

In practical terms, the club is designed to stay square with the putter path through the stroke.

Arc Putting Stroke

An arced stroke [R] refers to when the putter face will open and close relative to the target, and the stroke travels on a slight curve or arc.

For this, blade putters are usually best because of their natural toe-weighting.

How Do You ‘Feel’?

So we’ve gone through the 2 kinds of strokes that can affect your decision. Now, let’s go through the feel.

Roll Quality

This is one of the most important factors you need to pay attention to when looking at mallet putters.

The roll quality is critical to getting the ball along the target line with minimal skidding and hopping [R], so you’re sure it makes it into the hole.

All golfers will want to get the ball off the clubface so it can start rolling forward the moment you make that swing.

Imagine a slow-mo video of a golfer putting. You’ll see that EXACT moment when the ball will come off the clubface.

Pay attention to how the ball skids and hops before it rolls forward. That’s natural.

BUT, the right putter will give you a more consistent roll and minimize this skidding and hopping as much as possible.

So, when it comes to rolling quality, remember that first-rate putters will reduce this particular deficiency, so you’re sure that you can count on your putter when you’re faced with an important putt.

Sightline

We’ve alluded to how the larger head of a mallet shape has multiple benefits. One of these advantages is that it gives you a better opportunity to get a solid bold sightline [R].

If you’re a player who needs more assistance in this aspect, mallet styles will greatly help you improve your game.

Accuracy when putting is CRITICAL. Remember that you can’t afford to be off, even by just 0.5 of a millimeter.

So, this particular feature in traditional mallet putters will make alignment easier and give you more accurate results.

Just note that some putters have more effective alignment aids or sightlines than others, so consider this if this particular feature is critical to you.

Putting style

Feel players [R] will typically choose a blade-style putter because of its better responsiveness.

This lets them feel how the ball reacts off the putter’s face, which gives them more control over their putting.

This responsiveness lets them make tiny adjustments to how they’re playing on the fly. Moreover, it may help give them more confidence.

Of course, we’ve mentioned that this disparity in responsiveness is no longer as substantial now as before. Mallets are now more responsive than ever before.

This is when trying out the putter BEFORE you purchase it matters.

But if responsiveness isn’t that important to your playing style, then this particular consideration won’t matter to you that much.

Forgiveness

Every golfer understands that not all shots will be perfect.

After all, you need to get worse before you get better. You know how an iron shot or drive can lose accuracy and distance if it finds the face of the club more towards the toe?

The same thing will happen with a putter. Anything you hit away from the center of the putter’s club face can also cause your shot to lose speed and miss your target line.

Forgiveness will lessen the chances of this, even when you end up making off-center hits. This is why HIGHER forgiveness is typically associated with beginners.

Mallet putters are known for having better forgiveness than their blade counterparts. Of course, this does not mean that blade putters have zero forgiveness. It’s just relatively lower.

Also, remember that NOT ALL mallet putters have the same forgiveness [R].

We recommend testing out your putter to see how well the club responds when the putts are not hit with the club’s center.

Aesthetics and Style

While this shouldn’t be your most important consideration, we can’t completely ignore the aesthetics of a putter. This can help give you confidence.

Moreover, each golfer will feel different when you are placing either a blade or mallet-style putter behind the ball at the address.

So, choosing the style which makes you feel most comfortable is an important fact to consider.

And now that you know about all the factors you need to consider when choosing between these 2 putter styles, you won’t be swayed by just the looks.

At the end of the day, the best putter for you, whether it’s a blade or mallet, will be whatever helps you improve your putting game.

Choosing the Best Mallet Putter: What To Consider

So now that you’ve decided on getting a mallet-style putter, how do you choose? Well, there are different factors.

Length

This is a critical consideration for ALL your golf clubs. This is a mistake most players make because they use a golf club that’s too long for them.

A putter that’s too long can negatively impact your game because it makes it difficult to square up the clubface continually.

To prevent this, we recommend having yourself measured to see if your golf clubs fit you properly.

Of course, the right length for you will also depend on your specific style and set-up, so your height isn’t the only factor that will affect the right length for you.

Head Size

Like we’ve said, mallet putters have bigger heads. But just HOW BIG do you want it to be?

Some of the best putters available out there extend 4 or 5 inches behind the clubhead. If this bothers you, make sure to check the size of the clubhead you’re getting.

However, remember that just because a club head is large doesn’t mean it will automatically be too heavy or awkward to control your ball speed.

To aid a lot of players, there’s perimeter weighting and the option to adjust the weight of the grip and shaft. These adjustable weights have made larger club heads just as effective as smaller ones.

Loft

All putters need a loft [R] because as the ball rests on the green and not a tee, it will push down slightly into the grass.

The loft of a mallet putter’s face will lift the ball up and onto the surface to give you a smoother roll.

Most mallet putters have a loft of roughly 3-4 degrees. Note that the putter doesn’t need a lot of lofts to get your golf ball rolling.

If the face had more loft than this, your putts would bounce more frequently, causing your roll to go off-line.

Also, remember how we told you about that moment right after impact when the ball skidded and bounced before starting to roll?

Well, one of the WORST things that can happen on a putt is when the golf ball bounces too much after impact.

You want to reduce the bouncing as much as possible, so putters with a low loft are better for you. This will help minimize the skidding and bouncing to keep the ball rolling forward along the target line.

Alignment Lines

We can’t stop raving about the excellent alignment lines you get on mallet putters. It’s probably one of our favorite features about them.

When you figure out how to use these lines to swing your club back and through the ball, you can consider yourself having unlocked an achievement. This will greatly help your golf game.

If you are going to go for a mallet-type putter head, choose one that takes advantage of the extra space and gives you some great sightlines. Otherwise, you’re missing out on this.

Also, note that there are many color combinations available out there, and some people don’t see the black or white lines and other colors.

Make sure you pick something that you can see VERY WELL. The colors are more than just for show here.

Putters And Grip Size

Finding the right grip size [R] is different with putters because it doesn’t only depend on your hand size. Even if you have small hands, you can use an oversized grip.

Midsize and jumbo putter grips [R] are best for helping players use more of their shoulders as opposed to their hands in their putting stroke.

The more you can do this, the easier it will be to consistently get the golf ball rolling towards the target.

Budget

Finally, we’ve come to one of the biggest determining factors in your choice of a putter. Putters can range from very affordable to expensive.

As a general rule, a high-quality putter will cost you a bit more. This is because it will typically use better materials.

Moreover, something that you may not see directly on the putter is all the research and development that went into designing it.

A Recap of the Best Mallet Putter Picks

Pinemeadow Golf Men’s PGX: Best Budget Pick

If you’re a beginner looking to get your first mallet putter, or you just want mallet putters for practice, this is an excellent option.

You don’t have to spend hundreds of dollars just to get a decent model to aid you as you perfect your putting stroke.

TaylorMade Golf Spider X Putter: Best Value Pick

If you’re a pro or serious golfer looking for a new putter that can help you get that golf ball in, this is one serious contender.

Between this and the other top putters, the right one for you will really depend on your putter fitting your playing style and personal preferences.

Odyssey Stroke Lab Black Putter: Best Overall Pick

This isn’t for the average golfer because of its price, but you certainly won’t be disappointed if you have the budget for it.

These are at the top of the list because there’s no other putter to give you the same distance control and consistent roll. This is the BEST mallet putter money can buy today.

Conclusion

Golf can be a challenging sport to learn if you’ve only been on the fine green grass ONCE.

We hope that these best mallet putters will give you an easier time learning and mastering the sport. Before you know it, you’ll be able to swing like a PRO!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *